Home  |  About Us  |  Contacts  |  Products    
 News Items
 Top Stories
 News Briefs
 Also Featuring
 Movie Reviews
 Sunday Scripture
 CNS Blog
 Links to Clients
 Major Events
 2008 papal visit
 World Youth Day
 John Paul II
 For Clients
 Client Login
 CNS Insider
 We're also on ...
 RSS Feeds
 Top Stories
 Movie Reviews
 CNS Blog
 For More Info

 If you would like
 more information
 about Catholic
 News Service,
 please contact
 CNS at one of
 the following:
 (202) 541-3250


 This material
 may not
 be published,
 rewritten or
 except by
 linking to
 a page on
 this site.

  Movie Review

Somewhere Between

By Kurt Jensen
Catholic News Service

NEW YORK (CNS) -- Happily ever after can be an elusive goal when it comes to international adoptions, as the documentary "Somewhere Between" (Long Shot Factory) explains.

Eighty thousand Chinese children, most of them girls, have been adopted in the United States since 1991, when China -- which imposed a strict, morally unacceptable "one child" law in 1979 -- loosened adoption procedures. They're mostly girls because in China, tradition requires the son to take care of elderly parents. This puts girls without brothers at risk, and that's especially so for girls in poor families.

The film by Linda Goldstein Knowlton, herself the mother of an adopted child from China, explores what occurs in adolescence when adoptees, who are seldom, if ever, actual orphans, want to be in touch with their original culture and, if possible, their birth parents. How do they re-connect?

Knowlton's film is an unvarnished look at the awkwardness involved, mostly using the words of the adoptees themselves, all now part of white or mixed-race families. She follows four teen girls: Fang "Jenni" Lee of Berkeley, Calif.; Haley Butler of Nashville, Tenn.; Ann Boccuti of Lansdale, Pa.; and Jenna Cook of Newburyport, Mass.

All are shown to live happily and comfortably in the United States, although they also good-naturedly mention that they've encountered racist remarks at school. Sometimes they refer to themselves as "bananas" (yellow on the outside, white on the inside) or "scrambled eggs."

The value of adoption, and each family's reason for choosing adoption, are not explored. The question under consideration is what kind of identity these girls intend to have as adults.

They're Chinese and they're American, but they're not Chinese-American, so they can feel rootless. "Whether I'm in America or China, they know I'm a foreigner," Lee explains.

Lee and Butler speak Chinese and make connections to their homeland -- Butler to her birth parents and Chinese siblings, Lee to the Dai people of southwest China from which she springs. Lee also helps her family adopt a disabled Chinese child. Boccuti, adopted as an infant, and Cook express less curiosity.

All the families are active in Chinese Adoption Links International, a support organization. There's also a scene with a spokesman for United Adoptees International, a group that opposes all international adoptions. Korean adoptees, particularly, it seems, have been told they're orphans but have been found to have falsified records.

Only in Butler's life is religion a prominent factor. She is an aspiring musician whose family belongs to an evangelical church -- and who sport an anti-abortion/pro-adoption bumper sticker on their minivan.

"People tell me I'm lucky to live in America," she says. "I am really lucky -- but something bigger had something to do with that."

Visiting China, the Butlers have an emotional, somewhat unsettling, meeting with Haley's birth family in their hotel room.

"They're religious -- they believe in Christianity," the translator explains.

Jeannie Butler, the adoptive mother, keeps her questions simple, but comments: "We wanted to know who abandoned her."

The answer turns out to be complicated, since Haley's original family, without the means to support the girl, gave her to relatives, who then deposited her at the orphanage. After the birth mother bursts into tears at the sight of the girl, why, viewers may wonder, put her through an interrogation?

Knowlton's documentary should be mandatory viewing for anyone considering an international adoption.

The film contains mature themes. The Catholic News Service classification is A-II -- adults and adolescents. Not rated by the Motion Picture Association of America.

- - -

Jensen is a guest reviewer for Catholic News Service.


Copyright (c) 2012 Catholic News Service/USCCB. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or otherwise distributed.
CNS · 3211 Fourth St NE · Washington DC 20017 · 202.541.3250


   Looking for a
   movie review?

Movie List

   Click "Movie List"
   button above
   Enter a keyword
   from the movie
   title in the box
   below and click
   the "Search"